Introduction
Hello investors! Today we’re diving deep into Singapore’s REIT market and comparing two increasingly popular investment vehicles: Syfe REIT+ and traditional REIT ETFs. In a financial landscape where property prices continue to rise, REITs offer ordinary investors a chance to own a slice of premium real estate without the hefty capital requirements or management headaches.
But which vehicle is better for accessing these investments? By the end of this video, you’ll understand the nuanced differences between Syfe REIT+ and REIT ETFs, and more importantly, which might be better aligned with your personal investment strategy.
The Singapore REIT Landscape in 2025
Before we compare these investment vehicles, let’s take a moment to understand the Singapore REIT market in 2025. Singapore has established itself as one of Asia’s premier REIT hubs, with over 40 listed REITs and property trusts valued at approximately S$100 billion.
Singapore REITs have historically offered attractive dividend yields between 4-7%, significantly higher than government bonds or fixed deposits. This yield premium has made them particularly attractive in the current economic environment, despite the challenges posed by interest rate fluctuations.
What Are They?
Syfe REIT+
Syfe REIT+ is a specialized portfolio offering from Syfe, a digital wealth management platform launched in 2019. This investment product creates a portfolio of 20 carefully selected Singapore REITs, designed to track the iEdge S-REIT Leaders index.
What makes Syfe REIT+ unique is that when you invest, Syfe actually purchases the underlying REITs on your behalf—you own the actual REIT units, not shares in a fund that owns REITs. This creates a direct ownership structure that has several implications we’ll explore shortly.
REIT ETFs
REIT ETFs are exchange-traded funds that trade on the Singapore Exchange (SGX). The most comparable ones to Syfe REIT+ include:
- CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF – Launched in 2020, this ETF tracks the same index as Syfe REIT+.
- Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF – Tracks the Morningstar Singapore REIT Yield Focus Index.
- NikkoAM-Straits Trading Asia Ex-Japan REIT ETF – Provides broader exposure to REITs across Asia.
- Phillip SGX APAC Dividend Leaders REIT ETF – Focuses on high-dividend REITs across the Asia-Pacific region.
Unlike Syfe REIT+, when you purchase shares of these ETFs, you’re buying into a fund structure—you don’t directly own the underlying REITs.
Deep Dive: Structure and Ownership
The Direct Ownership Advantage
With Syfe REIT+, you’re the beneficial owner of the actual REITs. This creates several interesting implications:
- Tax Efficiency – There’s no additional layer of corporate taxation as might occur in some fund structures.
- Transparency – You can see exactly which REITs you own and in what proportions.
- Corporate Actions – You participate directly in rights issues and other corporate actions.
In contrast, ETFs operate as a separate entity that owns the REITs. When you buy an ETF share, you’re one step removed from the underlying assets. This creates a cleaner, simpler ownership experience but adds that additional layer between you and the actual REITs.
Portfolio Construction Methodology
Syfe REIT+ doesn’t just passively track the index—it employs an optimized approach. The portfolio managers aim to achieve low tracking error while maintaining sufficient liquidity, sometimes by adjusting weightings of certain REITs.
REIT ETFs typically follow strict index-tracking methodologies with minimal active management. This creates predictability but may sometimes result in overexposure to certain sectors or properties based solely on market capitalization.
Fees and Costs: The Hidden Impact on Returns
Syfe REIT+ Fee Structure
Syfe REIT+ uses a tiered fee structure based on your total investment across all Syfe products:
- 0.65% annually for investments under S$50,000 (Basic tier)
- 0.55% annually for S$50,000 to S$250,000 (Black tier)
- 0.45% annually for S$250,000 to S$1,000,000 (Gold tier)
- 0.35% annually for investments above S$1,000,000 (Platinum tier)
These are all-in fees—no additional transaction costs, platform fees, or custody charges. This simplicity makes it easier to calculate your true investment costs.
REIT ETF Cost Layers
REIT ETFs have multiple cost components that can be less transparent:
- Management Fee – Typically 0.5% to 0.95% annually
- Brokerage Commissions – Usually around 0.08% to 0.28% per transaction
- Bid-Ask Spreads – The CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF, for example, had an average bid-ask spread of about 0.15% in 2024
- Custody and Clearing Fees – Additional small fees charged by brokerages
For buy-and-hold investors, these transaction costs may be minimal, but for regular traders or dollar-cost averagers, they can significantly impact returns over time.
The Compound Impact of Fee Differences
Let’s put this into perspective: A 0.3% difference in annual fees on a S$50,000 investment compounds to approximately S$3,600 over 20 years, assuming a 6% annual return. This isn’t insignificant, especially when considering that REITs are often held as long-term income investments.
Dividend Treatment: Compounding’s Hidden Power
Syfe REIT+ Dividend Reinvestment
One of Syfe REIT+’s most compelling features is automatic dividend reinvestment. When your REITs distribute dividends, Syfe automatically reinvests them into your portfolio at no additional cost.
This creates a powerful compounding effect. For instance, a portfolio with a 5% dividend yield that reinvests all dividends will grow approximately 28% more over 10 years compared to one that doesn’t reinvest, assuming stable prices.
This automatic reinvestment is unavailable for the Basic and Black tiers (investments under S$100,000). For higher tiers, dividends can be withdrawn if preferred.
ETF Dividend Distribution
Most Singapore REIT ETFs distribute dividends semi-annually or quarterly directly to your brokerage account or designated bank account. While this provides regular income, it creates what investment professionals call “cash drag”—idle money not working for you.
To reinvest these dividends, you’d need to manually make additional ETF purchases, incurring transaction fees each time. For smaller dividend amounts, these fees might make reinvestment impractical until you’ve accumulated a larger sum.
Liquidity and Trading: When Timing Matters
The ETF Liquidity Advantage
REIT ETFs offer a significant advantage in liquidity and trading flexibility:
- Intraday Trading – You can buy or sell at any time during market hours.
- Limit Orders – You can set specific price points for execution.
- Stop-Loss Orders – You can automate your risk management.
- Immediate Execution – Trades are completed within seconds.
This flexibility can be crucial during market volatility or when you need immediate access to capital.
Syfe REIT+ Execution Timeline
Syfe REIT+ operates on a different timeline:
- Trade Execution – Buy orders typically take 1-2 business days to execute.
- Withdrawal Processing – Selling REITs and withdrawing funds usually takes 3-4 business days.
- No Intraday Timing – You cannot time your entry or exit within the trading day.
For long-term investors, this delay may be inconsequential. However, for those who value precise market timing or might need emergency liquidity, this is an important consideration.
Risk Management: The Hybrid Approach
Syfe’s Unique Risk Management Option
Syfe offers an innovative option called “REITs with Risk Management,” which incorporates Singapore government bonds alongside REITs. This creates a hybrid portfolio with:
- Volatility Dampening – Government bonds typically have lower volatility than REITs.
- Dynamic Allocation – The REIT-to-bond ratio adjusts based on market conditions.
- Downside Protection – During market turbulence, the bond component helps stabilize portfolio value.
According to Syfe’s backtesting, this approach has historically reduced portfolio drawdowns by approximately 20-30% during market corrections while capturing about 80-90% of the upside during bull markets.
The Pure REIT Exposure of ETFs
Standard REIT ETFs offer pure REIT exposure with no built-in risk management mechanisms. During the 2020 COVID-19 downturn, for example, Singapore REIT ETFs declined by approximately 35-40%, while Syfe’s risk-managed portfolio limited losses to around 25-30%.
This difference highlights an important philosophical distinction: REIT ETFs offer pure market exposure, while Syfe’s risk-managed option prioritizes risk-adjusted returns.
Performance Analysis: Beyond Raw Returns
Historical Performance Context
From 2020 to early 2025, Singapore REITs experienced significant volatility:
- COVID-19 Impact (2020) – Sharp 35-40% decline followed by partial recovery
- Inflation Concerns (2022-2023) – Pressure from rising interest rates
- Stabilization (2024-2025) – Moderate recovery as interest rate expectations moderated
During this period, Syfe REIT+ reportedly outperformed some comparable REIT ETFs by about 1-2% annually after fees. However, this outperformance varied based on which risk management option was selected.
The Risk-Adjusted Perspective
Raw returns don’t tell the complete story. When analyzing through the lens of risk-adjusted metrics:
- Sharpe Ratio – Syfe’s risk-managed portfolio generally achieved a higher Sharpe ratio (return per unit of risk).
- Maximum Drawdown – Syfe’s risk-managed option experienced smaller maximum drawdowns.
- Volatility – The standard deviation of returns was typically lower for Syfe’s risk-managed portfolio.
These metrics suggest that while pure REIT ETFs might occasionally deliver higher raw returns during strong bull markets, Syfe’s approach may provide a smoother investment journey.
Specialized Investment Strategies
Sector and Geographical Tilting
Some investors prefer to overweight specific REIT sectors or geographical areas based on their market outlook. For example, in 2025, many analysts are bullish on industrial REITs due to e-commerce growth and data center REITs due to AI infrastructure demand.
REIT ETFs offer varying exposures:
- CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF: Diversified Singapore exposure
- NikkoAM-Straits Trading Asia Ex-Japan REIT ETF: Broader Asian exposure including markets like Hong Kong and Australia
Syfe REIT+ remains focused primarily on Singapore REITs, limiting geographical diversification opportunities.
Dollar-Cost Averaging Considerations
For investors practicing dollar-cost averaging (regular fixed investments), the fee structure becomes particularly important:
- Syfe REIT+ allows fee-free regular contributions of any amount, making it highly efficient for small, frequent investments.
- REIT ETFs can become cost-prohibitive for small regular investments due to minimum brokerage fees, though some brokerages now offer reduced fees for regular savings plans.
Tax Implications for Different Investor Types
Singapore Residents
For Singapore residents, dividends from Singapore REITs are generally tax-exempt at the individual level, regardless of whether received through Syfe REIT+ or REIT ETFs.
International Investors
For international investors, the tax situation becomes more complex:
- Syfe REIT+ – As the beneficial owner of the REITs, international investors may face withholding taxes based on their country’s tax treaties with Singapore.
- REIT ETFs – The ETF structure might create different tax implications depending on the investor’s jurisdiction and applicable tax treaties.
Who Should Choose Which Option?
Ideal Syfe REIT+ Investors:
- Long-Term Income Investors – Those focused on dividend reinvestment and compounding
- Risk-Conscious Investors – Those who value downside protection over maximum returns
- Hands-Off Investors – Those who prefer a more managed approach
- Regular Small Investors – Those making frequent small contributions where transaction costs matter
- Beginning Investors – Those who value simplicity and all-in-one solutions
Ideal REIT ETF Investors:
- Active Traders – Those who value liquidity and precise market timing
- Tactical Asset Allocators – Those who adjust exposures based on market conditions
- Integration-Focused Investors – Those who want REITs as part of a broader brokerage portfolio
- Regional Diversification Seekers – Those looking for specific geographical exposures
- Technical Traders – Those who use technical analysis and specific order types
A Hybrid Approach: The Best of Both Worlds?
Some sophisticated investors adopt a hybrid approach:
- Core-Satellite Strategy – Using Syfe REIT+ as a core holding for automatic dividend reinvestment, while using REIT ETFs for tactical positions
- Risk-Tiered Approach – Allocating long-term funds to Syfe’s risk-managed option while using pure REIT ETFs for higher risk/return potential
- Life-Stage Adaptation – Starting with Syfe’s simplicity during wealth accumulation, then transitioning to ETFs during retirement for income control
Future Trends to Watch
Looking ahead, several trends might influence the comparative advantages of these investment vehicles:
- Fee Compression – Both robo-advisors and ETFs continue to experience downward fee pressure
- Platform Integration – Increased connectivity between investment platforms
- New Product Development – Both Syfe and ETF providers continue to innovate
- Regulatory Changes – Singapore’s regulatory environment continues to evolve for financial products
Conclusion
Both Syfe REIT+ and REIT ETFs offer viable paths to Singapore REIT investing, each with distinct advantages aligned with different investor profiles.
The choice ultimately depends on your personal investment philosophy, time horizon, and priorities. Syfe REIT+ offers a more managed, cost-effective approach with automatic dividend reinvestment and risk management, while REIT ETFs provide greater liquidity, trading flexibility, and potentially broader exposures.
Remember that regardless of which vehicle you choose, Singapore REITs themselves offer an attractive combination of income and growth potential, making them a valuable component of a diversified investment portfolio.
The most important factor isn’t necessarily which vehicle you choose, but rather that you start investing in this asset class with a clear strategy aligned with your long-term financial goals.
Thanks for watching! If you found this comparison helpful, be sure to like, subscribe, and share your thoughts in the comments below.
FAQ: Syfe REIT+ vs REIT ETFs
What is the difference between Syfe REIT+ vs REIT ETF?
Syfe REIT+ and REIT ETFs are both investment options for gaining exposure to Singapore’s real estate market, but they have several key differences:
Structure and Management
Syfe REIT+ is not an ETF but a portfolio of 20 REITs that aims to track the iEdge S-REIT Leaders index4. When investing in Syfe REIT+, you own actual units of the underlying REITs, whereas with REIT ETFs, you purchase shares of the ETF itself14.
Fees and Costs
Syfe REIT+ generally offers lower fees, ranging from 0.25% to 0.65% depending on the invested amount3. These are all-in fees with no additional charges for transactions or ETF expenses3. REIT ETFs typically have management fees and ongoing charges, plus potential brokerage fees for transactions34.
Dividend Reinvestment
Syfe REIT+ automatically reinvests dividends for investors below the Black tier (min $20,000 portfolio)5. REIT ETFs often do not offer automatic dividend reinvestment4.
Minimum Investment and Accessibility
Both Syfe REIT+ and REIT ETFs offer low barriers to entry. Syfe REIT+ has no minimum investment requirement, while REIT ETFs can be purchased in single units4.
Risk Management
Syfe offers a “REITs with Risk Management” option that includes bonds to reduce portfolio volatility1. This feature is not typically available with standard REIT ETFs.
Performance
As of 2024, Syfe REIT+ has reportedly outperformed some REIT ETFs, even after accounting for fees3. However, past performance does not guarantee future results.
Liquidity and Trading
REIT ETFs are traded on the stock exchange, providing intraday liquidity7. Syfe REIT+ is not traded on the market, so there’s no concept of bid-ask spreads or market liquidity7.
In conclusion, Syfe REIT+ offers a managed, cost-effective approach with automatic dividend reinvestment and risk management options, while REIT ETFs provide the familiarity and liquidity of exchange-traded securities. The choice between them depends on individual investment goals, preferences for management, and desired features.
Rewrite
What are the main advantages of Syfe REIT+ over REIT ETFs?
Syfe REIT+ offers several advantages over traditional REIT ETFs:
Cost-Effectiveness
- Lower overall fees: Syfe REIT+ charges all-in fees ranging from 0.25% to 0.65%, depending on the invested amount, with no additional transaction or ETF expenses4.
- No brokerage fees: Unlike REIT ETFs, Syfe REIT+ doesn’t incur brokerage fees for buying or selling16.
- No bid-ask spreads: Syfe REIT+ eliminates the bid-ask spreads associated with ETF trading1.
Investment Structure and Management
- Direct REIT ownership: Investors own actual units of the underlying REITs, rather than shares of an ETF36.
- Automatic dividend reinvestment: Syfe REIT+ reinvests dividends at no extra cost, potentially adding 0.4% to 0.5% in annual returns56.
- Portfolio optimization: Syfe REIT+ uses an optimized allocation of 20 REITs to achieve a low tracking error while maintaining liquidity3.
- Risk management option: Investors can choose a “REITs with Risk Management” portfolio that includes bonds to reduce volatility4.
Flexibility and Accessibility
- No minimum investment: Syfe REIT+ allows investors to start with any amount, making it accessible to beginners17.
- Regular contributions: Investors can easily make regular investments without incurring additional fees6.
- Liquidity: Withdrawals can be made anytime without charges6.
Performance
As of 2024, Syfe REIT+ has reportedly outperformed some REIT ETFs, even after accounting for fees4.
In conclusion, Syfe REIT+ offers a more cost-effective, flexible, and managed approach to REIT investing compared to traditional REIT ETFs, making it an attractive option for both novice and experienced investors seeking exposure to Singapore’s real estate market.
What are the potential downsides of investing in Syfe REIT+?
While Syfe REIT+ offers several advantages, there are potential downsides to consider:
Performance Concerns
- Recent underperformance: As of Q3 2023, the REIT+(100% REITs) portfolio declined by 3.8%, erasing its year-to-date gains5.
- Sensitivity to interest rates: REITs are generally sensitive to interest rate changes, which can negatively impact performance when rates rise5.
Strategy Limitations
- Limited diversification: The portfolio focuses solely on Singapore REITs, lacking global exposure4.
- Fixed strategy: Unlike some of Syfe’s other offerings, REIT+ doesn’t employ dynamic risk management strategies4.
Execution and Liquidity
- Delayed trade execution: Buy trades typically take about 1-2 business days to be executed, unlike ETFs which are instantly executed3.
- No intraday trading: Unlike REIT ETFs, there’s no ability to trade throughout the day6.
Transparency and Control
- Black box concerns: Some investors may find the strategy less transparent compared to directly choosing individual REITs1.
- Limited control: Investors cannot select specific REITs or adjust individual weightings within the portfolio4.
Potential Behavioral Issues
- Investor behavior: As with other robo-advisors, there’s a risk that investors may frequently switch between portfolios in response to market movements, potentially harming long-term returns1.
Fees and Costs
- Fee structure: While competitive, the fees (ranging from 0.4% to 0.65%) may still be higher than some ultra-low-cost ETF options for larger investors4.
- Hidden costs: Although there are no explicit transaction fees, the cost of trades is likely built into the overall fee structure6.
In conclusion, while Syfe REIT+ offers a convenient and relatively low-cost way to invest in Singapore REITs, investors should carefully consider these potential downsides in light of their investment goals and risk tolerance.
How does Syfe REIT+ manage risk during market volatility?
Syfe REIT+ employs several strategies to manage risk during market volatility:
Automated Risk Management
Syfe REIT+ uses a proprietary algorithm to adjust portfolio allocations in response to market conditions:
- During periods of increased volatility, the algorithm reduces REIT exposure and increases allocation to government bonds14.
- When volatility decreases, the REIT allocation is increased to potentially deliver better returns16.
Portfolio Composition
- The risk-managed portfolio always maintains a minimum 50% allocation to REITs to ensure exposure to the property market and maintain dividend yield12.
- As of March 2025, the risk-managed portfolio typically aims for a long-term composition of around 70% REITs and 30% bonds4.
Bond Integration
- The risk-managed portfolio incorporates AAA-rated Singapore government bonds to provide stability during market turbulence2.
- This bond allocation helps cushion the portfolio during market pullbacks1.
Volatility Reduction
The risk management strategy is designed to lower overall portfolio volatility compared to a conventional REIT portfolio3. This approach aims to provide higher risk-adjusted returns over time.
Downside Risk Management
Syfe’s algorithm adjusts allocations to keep the overall portfolio risk within a 15% Downside Risk band5. This helps limit excessive portfolio fluctuations and provides investors with more confidence to hold their investments during market downturns.
By implementing these risk management strategies, Syfe REIT+ aims to balance yield potential with capital preservation, allowing investors to navigate market volatility more comfortably.
Which s reit etf are comparable to syfe reit?
Several Singapore REIT ETFs are comparable to Syfe REIT+ in terms of exposure to Singapore REITs and tracking similar indices. Here are the main options:
Comparable Singapore REIT ETFs
CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF
- Underlying Index: Tracks the same iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index as Syfe REIT+.
- Dividend Yield: 6.0% (as of Jan 2024)6.
- Expense Ratio: 0.6%6.
- Geographical Exposure: Primarily Singapore (64%), with some exposure to Australia, the U.S., China, Hong Kong, Japan, and others6.
- Key Features:
- Offers instant trade execution on SGX.
- Semi-annual dividend payouts.
- Includes 21 holdings with top names like CapitaLand Ascendas REIT and Mapletree Logistics Trust6.
Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF
- Underlying Index: Morningstar® Singapore REIT Yield Focus Index.
- Dividend Yield: 5.0% (as of Jan 2024)6.
- Expense Ratio: 0.6%6.
- Geographical Exposure: Focused entirely on Singapore REITs6.
- Key Features:
- Semi-annual dividend payouts.
- Tracks high-yielding REITs with strong financial health.
- Includes top holdings like CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust and Keppel DC REIT6.
NikkoAM-Straits Trading Asia Ex-Japan REIT ETF
- Underlying Index: FTSE EPRA Nareit Asia ex Japan REITs 10% Capped Index.
- Dividend Yield: 5.80% (as of Jan 2024)6.
- Expense Ratio: 0.55%6.
- Geographical Exposure: Broader coverage across Asia excluding Japan, including Singapore6.
- Key Features:
- Quarterly dividend payouts.
- Provides exposure to faster-growing markets outside of Singapore.
Phillip SGX APAC Dividend Leaders REIT ETF
- Underlying Index: iEdge APAC Ex-Japan Dividend Leaders REIT Index.
- Dividend Yield: 4.10% (as of Jan 2024)6.
- Expense Ratio: 0.95%6.
- Geographical Exposure: Focuses on Asia-Pacific regions, including Australia and Singapore24.
Comparison to Syfe REIT+
Syfe REIT+ differs from these ETFs primarily due to its optimized allocation strategy, automatic dividend reinvestment, and inclusion of risk management options (e.g., bond allocation). However, ETFs like the CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF and Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF are more liquid, offer intraday trading, and may have slightly lower fees depending on transaction costs.
Investors should evaluate their priorities—such as liquidity, dividend reinvestment, geographical exposure, and fees—when choosing between Syfe REIT+ and these ETFs.
-
Syfe REIT+ vs REIT ETFs: Which Should Investors Choose?
Introduction Hello investors! Today we’re diving deep into Singapore’s REIT market and comparing two increasingly popular investment vehicles: Syfe REIT+ and traditional REIT ETFs. In a financial landscape…
4 min read
-
Syfe REIT+ Is the smart invertor’s secret weapon?
INTRODUCTION Welcome to our in-depth analysis of Syfe REIT+, one of Singapore’s most innovative investment products for gaining exposure to the real estate market. I’m [Name], and today…
4 min read
-
Asia’s Private Market Revolution: Inside Tikehau Amova’s Game-Changing Venture
Today we’re diving into what might be the most significant private markets partnership of 2025. Nikko Asset Management and Tikehau Capital have joined forces to create Tikehau Amova…
4 min read
-
What Happens to REITs When Interest Rates Rise?
Today we’re diving into a topic that’s crucial for real estate investors: what happens to REITs when interest rates rise. If you’ve been watching the markets, you know…
4 min read
-
Why Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF Could Be Your Hidden Gem?
23 Premium REITs in One Investment | 2025 Analysis Think of the Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF as a carefully curated basket of Singapore’s premier real estate investment trusts. Launched…
4 min read